A smiling young woman in a rust-coloured vest top raises her fist while holding white bathroom scales against a pink wall

Can You Lose Weight on Keto? What UK Guidance Says

Quick answer

Can you lose weight on the keto diet? UK guidance doesn't single out keto. NICE says diets for weight management in adults should "keep the person's total energy intake below their energy expenditure", and that this could be done with low-fat or low-carbohydrate diets, or other methods. The British Dietetic Association (BDA) says: "The evidence shows that low carb diets are effective for both weight loss and improving glycaemic control in type 2 diabetes, but that they are no more effective than many other diets." If you're thinking about keto to lose weight, speak to your GP or a registered dietitian first.

At a glance

  • Calorie deficitwhat NICE says adult weight-management diets need, whether low-fat, low-carbohydrate or another approach
  • 20–50gcarbs a day on a very low carb (ketogenic) diet, per the BDA
  • Probably little to no differencein weight lost on low-carb and balanced-carb diets for up to two years (Cochrane review)
  • 0.5 to 1kga week, the NHS's suggested aim when losing weight
On this page
  1. Can you lose weight on the keto diet?
  2. What counts as a keto diet?
  3. What the evidence says about low carb diets and weight
  4. Rapid weight loss and restrictive diets
  5. Limits and things to weigh up
  6. Who should get advice first
  7. Where to get support
  8. FAQs
  9. Sources

This guide sets out what NICE, the NHS, the BDA, the British Nutrition Foundation (BNF) and a Cochrane review say about low carb and keto diets and weight, where the evidence runs out, and who should get advice before changing their diet. It isn't personal advice, and we're not suggesting keto as a way to lose weight. For a wider look at the diet, see our guide to the pros and cons of keto. For the 800–1,000 calorie plan, see our explainer on what the Fast 800 Keto is.

Can you lose weight on the keto diet?

UK guidance answers this question about weight in general, not about keto. NICE's 2025 guideline on overweight and obesity management says: "Ensure that dietary approaches for adults to support overweight and obesity management keep the person's total energy intake below their energy expenditure (also called an energy deficit or calorie deficit). This could be done by lowering specific macronutrient content (for example, low-fat or low-carbohydrate diets) or using other methods to limit overall energy intake."

The NHS explains the same idea on its Understanding calories page: "To stay at around the same weight, the calories your body uses should be the same as the amount of calories you eat and drink." It adds that "you're likely to lose weight if you eat and drink fewer calories than you use." The BNF puts it this way: "To lose weight, you need to create a calorie deficit in your diet. That means you need to burn more calories than you consume."

So NICE gives low-carbohydrate diets as one example of how an energy deficit "could be done", alongside low-fat diets and other methods, and its dietary recommendations don't mention ketogenic diets by name. We haven't found guidance from NICE, the NHS, the BDA or the BNF that recommends a ketogenic diet for weight loss over other approaches.

What counts as a keto diet?

The BDA's low carb diets fact sheet sorts diets by how much carbohydrate they provide each day. It says: "Overall, low carb diets are usually defined as those that provide less than 130g of carbs each day."

Type of diet (BDA) Carbs (g a day)
Very low carb (ketogenic) 20–50g
Low carb 50–130g
Moderate carb 130–220g
High carb More than 225g

BDA Low carb diets food fact sheet (October 2019). Figures as printed by the BDA.

The BDA says sugary and starchy foods such as bread, potatoes, pasta and rice "are generally avoided on a low carb diet", while foods such as milk, natural yoghurt, fruit, green leafy vegetables and salad "can be included". For a sample day of meals and their carbs, see our low-carb meal plan.

What the evidence says about low carb diets and weight

The BDA. Under the question "Are low carb diets more effective than other diets?", the BDA's fact sheet says: "The evidence shows that low carb diets are effective for both weight loss and improving glycaemic control in type 2 diabetes, but that they are no more effective than many other diets. There is no single diet that suits everyone, and it is advised that you choose a diet that fits with your lifestyle, has minimum impact on your quality of life, and which you feel you can maintain over the long-term. It is also important that you choose a diet that meets your nutritional needs."

NICE. Explaining its 2025 recommendations, NICE's committee says: "The committee recognised that macronutrient diets are increasingly popular, but they vary in the approach to macronutrient balance and the evidence did not favour a particular approach. They noted that many of the studies compared low-carbohydrate diets with 'conventional' diets that were typically low-fat. Generally, the evidence could not differentiate between the approaches." It goes on: "So the committee agreed they could not recommend specific types of macronutrient diets and that different approaches to lowering macronutrient content, by reducing either fat or carbohydrate intake, could be used to create the energy deficit needed."

A Cochrane review. A Cochrane systematic review published in 2022 compared low-carbohydrate and balanced-carbohydrate weight-reducing diets in adults living with overweight or obesity. It found 61 trials involving 6,925 people, and nearly half of the trials (26) were in the USA. Its first key message is: "There is probably little to no difference in the weight lost by people following low-carbohydrate weight-reducing diets (also known as 'low-carb diets') compared to the weight lost by people following balanced-carbohydrate weight-reducing diets, for up to two years."

The review also says: "People lost weight on both diets in some trials. The amount of weight lost on average varied greatly with both diets across the trials from less than 1 kg in some trials and up to about 12 kg in others in the short term and long term." On side effects, it says: "We could not draw any conclusions about unwanted effects reported by participants because very few trials reported these." The evidence it reviewed runs to June 2021.

Rapid weight loss and restrictive diets

The BDA's fad diets fact sheet gives a list of diets to "stay away from". Two of the entries are diets that "Promise rapid weight loss of more than 1kg (2lb) of body fat a week such as keto or fasting." and diets that "Promote the avoidance or severe limitation of a whole food group. This could be dairy products, carbohydrates, or a staple food such as wheat. Examples include low carbohydrate diets, the 'carnivore diet' or 'paleo diet'."

The same fact sheet says: "Many fad diets will lead to initial results that may be short lived or have unintended consequences. For example, cutting out carbohydrates can mean a drop in your fibre intake, leading to gut problems such as constipation and bloating. Rapid weight loss may involve the loss of lean muscle and fluid, not just body fat."

The NHS's Tips to help you lose weight page suggests you "aim to lose 1 to 2lbs, or 0.5 to 1kg, a week", and its list of things not to do starts with "do not lose weight suddenly with diets". The BNF says: "There are a whole range of other popular diets such as keto, paleo or raw food diets, some of which claim to have specific effects on health or to help with weight loss. However, those diets which do not follow the healthy eating principles are typically harder to stick to and may be detrimental to your overall health in the longer term."

NICE also says: "Advise people not to use restrictive diets that are nutritionally unbalanced, because they are ineffective in the long term and can be harmful." NICE doesn't name keto in that recommendation. Low-energy diets of 800–1,200 calories a day are a separate thing: NICE says to consider them only as part of a multicomponent strategy with long-term support from a specialist weight management service or another service for long-term conditions, for people living with obesity, or with overweight and type 2 diabetes. Our Fast 800 Keto explainer covers that guidance.

Limits and things to weigh up

Safety evidence is short term. The BDA says: "Studies of low carbohydrate diets have shown that they are safe over the short-term (up to one year). There is very little information about safety over the longer term and there are some concerns about dietary changes with low carb diets such as eating less fibre, more red and processed meat and more saturated fat. This may increase the risk of heart disease, some cancers and change the bacteria in the gut, but few studies have investigated this, so it is challenging to draw any firm conclusions."

Research gaps. One of NICE's recommendations for research asks: "What are the adverse events associated with different dietary approaches (for example, low-energy and very-low-energy diets, low-carbohydrate diets, intermittent fasting) for people living with overweight or obesity?"

Weight regain. NICE says dietary approaches should be tailored to each person, taking into account things such as food preferences, personal circumstances and other conditions, and "that in many cases weight regain may happen." It also says: "Ensure that any dietary approaches that maintain an energy deficit are offered with support (for example by an appropriately trained healthcare professional such as a Registered dietitian or registered nutritionist) and follow up to help people maintain any weight loss in the long term."

It differs from UK weight-loss advice. The BDA's weight loss fact sheet bases its advice on the Eatwell Guide. It suggests filling half your plate with fruit and vegetables, then says: "Split the other half of your plate between proteins (like lean meat, fish, tofu, beans or lentils) and starchy carbs (like wholegrain rice, pasta or bread)." It also says: "Avoid fad diets. They are extreme, restrictive and hard to stick with." On a low carb diet, the BDA's low carb fact sheet says starchy foods are generally avoided. NICE says: "Encourage people to eat a nutritionally balanced diet in the long term, consistent with other healthy eating advice."

Who should get advice first

The BDA's low carb diets fact sheet says: "Before deciding to follow a low carb diet it is important that you are aware of the supporting evidence, and if you have a medical condition you are advised to seek advice from a dietitian."

  • Pregnancy. The BDA says: "Ketogenic diets should not be followed by women who are pregnant." On the NHS's Weight gain in pregnancy page, under gaining too much weight, it says: "Putting on too much weight can affect your health and increase your blood pressure. But pregnancy isn't the time to go on a diet, as it may harm the health of the unborn child. It's important that you eat healthily."
  • Breastfeeding. The NHS's Keeping fit and healthy with a baby page says: "If you're breastfeeding and you're overweight, the best way to lose weight is by eating a healthy, balanced diet and taking regular, moderate exercise, such as a brisk walk for 30 minutes each day. This will not affect the quality or quantity of your breast milk." It adds: "If you join a weight-loss group, tell them that you have recently had a baby, and let them know if you're breastfeeding, so they can give you the right advice."
  • Under 18s. For children and young people, NICE says: "Focus on healthy eating rather than on overly restrictive diets." It also says: "Avoid a dietary approach alone. Ensure dietary recommendations are part of a multicomponent intervention and are age appropriate and consistent with healthy eating advice." The NHS's advice for parents of overweight children says to "aim to give them a healthy, balanced diet that includes fruit and vegetables, starchy foods, protein and dairy or dairy alternatives". If you're under 18, or worried about a child's weight, speak to a GP before changing your diet or theirs.
  • Type 1 diabetes. University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust says: "If you have type 1 diabetes and you want to reduce how much carbohydrate you eat, it is really important that you are supervised by a dietitian before you make this change, and while you are following this diet." It also says: "We do not recommend that people follow a very low carbohydrate diet, because at the moment there is no strong evidence that it is helpful for people with type 1 diabetes. But if you do want to try a very low carbohydrate diet (also called a ketogenic diet), we will support you with this." For people who do, it says: "Speak to your healthcare team so they can help you adjust your insulin to reduce your risk of hypos." NICE lists type 1 diabetes among the conditions to take into account when tailoring a diet.
  • Type 2 diabetes and medicines. The BDA says: "If you have type 2 diabetes, you may need to reduce some medication such as insulin or sulfonylureas to avoid hypoglycaemia, and this should be done under medical supervision."
  • Eating disorders. NICE lists "eating disorders or disordered eating" among the conditions to take into account when tailoring a diet. In its discussion of low-energy diets, NICE's committee says no evidence was identified on eating disorders developing with restrictive diets, but notes that, based on its experience and stakeholder feedback, "it is a common concern that people who show a preference for highly restrictive diets and fasting are more likely to be vulnerable to an eating disorder." The NHS says: "If you think you may have an eating disorder, see a GP as soon as you can." You can also call the Beat helpline on 0808 801 0677, which the NHS lists.
  • Other medical conditions. The NHS says: "A GP can also help you get support for any other conditions that might be affecting your weight, such as mental health conditions."
Check with your GP first

Speak to your GP, diabetes nurse or a registered dietitian before you make big changes to your diet. This is especially important if you have diabetes and take insulin or other medicines that can cause hypos, or take SGLT2 inhibitors, as your medication may need to change. The same goes if you're pregnant, breastfeeding or have a history of eating disorders.

Where to get support

The NHS says: "A GP can give you advice about losing weight safely and refer you for treatment". It lists weight management programmes, medicines and surgery, and says you can self-refer for some weight management programmes. To find out what's near you, it suggests checking your GP surgery's website or asking the reception staff, checking your integrated care board (ICB) website, or searching online for NHS weight management services.

The BDA's weight loss fact sheet says: "If you would like further help, please speak with your GP or healthcare team for a referral to a dietitian or local weight management programme." Its fad diets fact sheet adds: "Dietitians have legally recognised qualifications and are independently regulated health professionals with a protected title."

Key takeaways

  • UK guidance doesn't single out keto: NICE says adult weight-management diets need an energy deficit, which could come from low-fat or low-carbohydrate diets, or other methods.
  • The evidence doesn't favour one approach: the BDA says low carb diets are "no more effective than many other diets", and a Cochrane review found little to no difference in weight lost for up to two years.
  • The BDA gives keto as an example of diets that promise rapid weight loss of more than 1kg of body fat a week, which it says to stay away from. The NHS suggests aiming for 0.5 to 1kg a week.
  • Safety evidence is short term: the BDA says studies have shown low carb diets "are safe over the short-term (up to one year)", and that "there is very little information about safety over the longer term".
  • Get advice first if you're pregnant, breastfeeding, under 18, have diabetes, take medicines or have a history of eating disorders.

Frequently asked questions

Can you lose weight on the keto diet?

UK guidance doesn't single out keto. NICE says adult weight-management diets should keep energy intake below energy expenditure, for example with low-fat or low-carbohydrate diets. The BDA says: "The evidence shows that low carb diets are effective for both weight loss and improving glycaemic control in type 2 diabetes, but that they are no more effective than many other diets."

Is keto better than other diets for weight loss?

A Cochrane review of 61 trials found there is "probably little to no difference" in the weight lost on low-carbohydrate and balanced-carbohydrate weight-reducing diets for up to two years. NICE says the evidence "did not favour a particular approach", and its committee agreed it could not recommend specific types of macronutrient diets.

How fast should you lose weight?

The NHS suggests you "aim to lose 1 to 2lbs, or 0.5 to 1kg, a week" and advises against losing weight suddenly with diets. The BDA's fad diets fact sheet says to stay away from diets that promise rapid weight loss of more than 1kg (2lb) of body fat a week, and gives keto and fasting as examples.

What does the BDA say about low carb diet safety?

The BDA says studies have shown low carb diets "are safe over the short-term (up to one year)", but that there is very little information about safety over the longer term. It lists concerns about eating less fibre, more red and processed meat and more saturated fat, and says few studies have investigated their effects.

Who should get advice before trying keto to lose weight?

Speak to your GP or a registered dietitian first, especially if you're pregnant, breastfeeding, under 18, have diabetes, take medicines or have a history of eating disorders. The BDA says ketogenic diets should not be followed by women who are pregnant, and that anyone with a medical condition is advised to seek advice from a dietitian.

Sources

Back to blog
1 of 4