Clip-top glass jar of piccalilli with cauliflower florets, pickling onions and cucumber in mustard sauce, beside sliced ham and a wedge of cheddar on an oak table

What Is Piccalilli? Ingredients, Taste and Carbs

Quick answer

What is piccalilli? Piccalilli is an English relish of chopped vegetables, such as cauliflower, onion and cucumber, pickled in a mustard and turmeric sauce made with vinegar, salt and usually sugar. It was adapted from Indian pickles in the 18th century and is usually eaten with cold meats, pies and cheese. CoFID lists piccalilli at 17.6g of carbohydrate per 100g.

At a glance

  • Made fromchopped vegetables, vinegar, mustard and spices
  • FromEngland, 18th century
  • Old namesPaco-Lilla, India pickle, Piccalillo
  • Carbs17.6g per 100g, 14.8g of it sugars
On this page
  1. What is piccalilli?
  2. What goes into piccalilli
  3. Where piccalilli comes from
  4. Piccalilli vs Branston Pickle
  5. What to eat with piccalilli
  6. Carbs in piccalilli
  7. Piccalilli with our products
  8. FAQs
  9. Sources

Piccalilli is the jar of chunky vegetables in mustard sauce that BBC Food suggests serving with raised pies, ham or strong cheeses. If you've wondered what is piccalilli, this guide explains it: what goes into it, where the odd name comes from, how it differs from Branston Pickle, what to eat it with and how many carbs it has.

What is piccalilli?

Piccalilli is a relish from English cuisine made from chopped, pickled vegetables and spices. Wikipedia says it was adapted from Indian pickles in the 18th century, in a style that was meant to seem exotic but suited English tastes.

The Cambridge Dictionary defines piccalilli as "small pieces of different vegetables preserved in a mustard sauce, usually eaten with cold meat". BBC Food describes it as a "salty-sour pickle" and calls it "a true British classic".

How do you say piccalilli?

The Cambridge Dictionary gives the UK pronunciation as /ˌpɪk.əˈlɪl.i/, roughly "pick-uh-LIL-ee", with the stress on the third syllable. Its US pronunciation, /ˈpɪk.ə.lɪl.i/, puts the stress on the first syllable.

Where does the name come from?

Nobody knows for certain. Wikipedia says the name may be based on the English word "pickle", which comes from the Middle Dutch pekel. The Oxford English Dictionary traces it to 1758, when Hannah Glasse explained how "to make Paco-Lilla, or India Pickle" in The Art of Cookery Made Plain and Easy. Elizabeth Raffald called it "Piccalillo" in 1769, Richard Briggs wrote "Picca Lillo" in 1788, and the modern spelling appears in a 1789 advert in The Times.

What goes into piccalilli

Wikipedia says modern British recipes use vegetables such as cauliflower, onion, runner beans, carrot and courgette, seasoned with ginger, garlic, coriander, mustard and turmeric and pickled in vinegar, salt and sugar. Some use shallots in place of onions and add chilli. Here's how two well-known UK recipes compare:

Part BBC Food Great British Chefs
Vegetables Pickling onions, cauliflower, cucumber, French beans Cauliflower, onion, shallots, cucumber
Vinegar 750ml malt, cider or white wine 310ml white wine, 150ml malt
Spices Mustard powder, ginger, turmeric, mustard seeds, garlic Mustard powder, turmeric, red chilli
Sugar 175g light muscovado 50g caster
Thickener 2–3 tbsp cornflour 2g xanthan gum

From the BBC Food piccalilli recipe (makes 3–4 450g jars) and Josh Eggleton's piccalilli recipe for Great British Chefs. Checked 20 November 2026.

How piccalilli is made

Both recipes start by salting the vegetables. BBC Food tosses them in coarse rock salt and leaves them in a cool place for 12 hours, then rinses them, simmers them in spiced vinegar until tender, adds the sugar and thickens the pickle with cornflour until it's glossy and thick. The jars are then stored in a cool, dark place for 3–4 weeks before eating.

Josh Eggleton salts the vegetables for 24 hours, boils the vinegars with chilli, cooks the sugar, turmeric and mustard powder in the vinegar, then thickens the cooled sauce with xanthan gum using a stick blender. The vegetables are left to soak in it overnight and kept sealed in a clean jar in the fridge.

Where piccalilli comes from

Wikipedia says the earliest known piccalilli recipes are English, and that it was created in the colonial era as an adaptation of Indian pickles. An even earlier reference than Hannah Glasse's may be in Anne Blencowe's handwritten Receipt Book of about 1694, which has "To Pickle Lila, an Indian Pickle".

The early recipes took weeks. Glasse soaked ginger and long pepper, salted and sun-dried them with garlic, then added mustard seed and turmeric to white wine vinegar. Vegetables and fruit such as white cabbage, cauliflower, cucumber, melon, apple, French beans or plums were salted, dried and added "as the things come in season". Raffald's version used white cabbage, cauliflower, cucumber, radish pods, kidney beans and beetroot, and was left to stand for 12 days.

Crosse & Blackwell sold piccalilli commercially from the 19th century. Wikipedia also notes that Anglo-Indian cooks in the British Raj tried to recreate the piccalilli they'd enjoyed in Britain, making large barrels with cauliflowers and vegetable marrows.

Piccalilli in America

The relish travelled to North America, where it changed. In the north-eastern United States, Wikipedia says commercial piccalilli is based on sweet peppers or green tomatoes. In the Midwest it's a bright green, finely chopped gherkin relish nicknamed "neon relish" and used on Chicago-style hot dogs. In the South, a green tomato relish called chow-chow is sometimes called piccalilli too.

Piccalilli vs Branston Pickle

They're both British pickles with roots in Indian pickles, but they're quite different in the jar. Wikipedia describes Branston Pickle, first made in 1922 at Branston in Staffordshire, as diced vegetables including swede, carrots, onions and cauliflower in a sauce of vinegar, tomato, apple and spices, with a sweet, spicy, chutney-like texture. Piccalilli has a mustard sauce instead and, in CoFID, fewer carbs than sweet pickle.

Piccalilli Sweet pickle
Sauce Mustard and turmeric Vinegar, tomato, apple, spices
Taste Salty-sour Sweet and spicy
First made 1700s recipes 1922 (Branston)
Carbs per 100g 17.6g 28.0g

Description from Wikipedia (Piccalilli; Branston (brand)) and BBC Food. Carbs from CoFID 2021 codes 17-702 (Piccalilli) and 17-718 (Pickle, sweet). Checked 20 November 2026.

What to eat with piccalilli

BBC Food suggests serving piccalilli with raised pies, ham or strong cheeses, and using it to "perk up a picnic or snazz up a Scotch egg". Josh Eggleton calls it "simply the greatest accompaniment to rich terrines and cold meats". If you have ham left over after Christmas, it's an obvious match. Our guide to what gammon is and how it differs from ham covers the joint itself, and our low-carb guide to every part of the Christmas plate looks at the sauces and sides.

If you're ordering anything from us for Christmas, the last order date for Christmas delivery is 18 December 2026.

Carbs in piccalilli

CoFID, the UK's food composition dataset, has an entry for piccalilli based on 9 samples from 4 brands, covering mild, saucy and sweet kinds. Here's how it compares with other jars on the table:

Per 100g (CoFID) Carbs Sugars
Piccalilli 17.6g 14.8g
Sweet pickle 28.0g 24.6g
Tomato chutney 31.0g 28.1g
Mango chutney 48.3g 45.7g
Pickled beetroot 5.6g 5.6g
Pickled onions 4.9g 3.5g
Pickled gherkins 2.6g 2.4g

CoFID 2021 codes 17-702 (Piccalilli), 17-718 (Pickle, sweet), 17-345 (Chutney, tomato), 17-343 (Chutney, mango, sweet), 13-166 (Beetroot, pickled, drained), 13-309 (Onions, pickled, drained) and 13-246 (Gherkins, pickled, drained). Carbohydrate doesn't include fibre, as on UK labels. Checked 20 November 2026.

Most of piccalilli's carbohydrate is sugar: 14.8g of the 17.6g per 100g. A 30g spoonful works out at about 5.3g of carbohydrate (30 × 17.6 ÷ 100), of which about 4.4g is sugars. That's our calculation from CoFID; brands vary, so check the label on your jar.

The sugar comes from the recipe. BBC Food's version uses 175g of light muscovado sugar for 3–4 450g jars, which is roughly 10–13g of added sugar per 100g (175 ÷ 1,800 or 1,350 × 100), before the cornflour. Josh Eggleton's uses 50g of caster sugar.

Is piccalilli keto?

Piccalilli isn't carb-free, but a small spoonful can fit into a keto day if you count it. In CoFID, 14.8g of its 17.6g of carbohydrate per 100g is sugars, so the sugar in the recipe makes up most of it. Plain pickles such as gherkins and pickled onions have far fewer carbs per 100g in CoFID, and the sweet pickles and chutneys have more.

If you make your own, you control both. Josh Eggleton's recipe already swaps cornflour for 2g of xanthan gum, and you could cut the sugar right down. We haven't tested a version with less sugar, so treat that as an idea rather than a recipe, and keep homemade jars in the fridge as his recipe does.

Check with your GP first

Speak to your GP, diabetes nurse or a registered dietitian before you make big changes to your diet. This is especially important if you have diabetes and take insulin or other medicines that can cause hypos, or take SGLT2 inhibitors, as your medication may need to change. The same goes if you're pregnant, breastfeeding or have a history of eating disorders.

Piccalilli with our products

Piccalilli usually ends up in a sandwich or on the side of a cold plate, so here's how three of our products could fit in, based on what each product page shows.

  • The thickener. Xanthan Gum is what Josh Eggleton uses in place of cornflour. Ours comes in a 150g pouch, lists xanthan gum as the only ingredient and shows 4.6g of carbohydrate per 100g. The product page suggests adding it to sauces a small pinch at a time while whisking.
  • A ham and piccalilli sandwich. Low Carb Keto Bread is a multigrain sliced loaf with 2.3g of carbohydrate per slice and 16 slices in a 400g loaf.
  • A wrap instead. Low Carb Keto Wraps have 4.4g of carbohydrate per wrap and come 4 to a pack, each about 20 to 22cm across.
Groovy Keto Xanthan Gum 150g pouch

For thickening

Xanthan Gum

150g pouch

See the xanthan gum
Groovy Keto Low Carb Keto Bread loaf with slices

For sandwiches

Low Carb Keto Bread

2.3g carbs per slice · 400g

See the bread
Groovy Keto Low Carb Keto Wraps pack

For wraps

Low Carb Keto Wraps

4.4g carbs per wrap · 4 wraps

See the wraps

Product details are as shown on each product page. Free delivery on orders over £30.

Allergens and labels

Piccalilli is made with mustard, which is one of the 14 allergens that UK food law says businesses must tell you about. Our Low Carb Keto Bread contains cereals with gluten, soy and sesame seeds, and our Low Carb Keto Wraps contain gluten from wheat flour and may contain traces of soy and mustard. Always check the pack for full allergen information.

Key takeaways

  • Piccalilli is an English relish. Chopped vegetables in a mustard and turmeric sauce.
  • It's adapted from Indian pickles. Recipes date back to at least 1758.
  • It's not the same as Branston. Branston Pickle is sweet, brown and chutney-like.
  • It goes with cold meats. Ham, pies, terrines, Scotch eggs and strong cheese.
  • Most of the carbs are sugar. 17.6g per 100g in CoFID, 14.8g of it sugars.

Frequently asked questions

How do you pronounce piccalilli?

The Cambridge Dictionary gives the UK pronunciation as /ˌpɪk.əˈlɪl.i/, which sounds like "pick-uh-LIL-ee", with the stress on the third syllable. The US pronunciation it gives puts the stress at the start instead, as "PICK-uh-lil-ee". Early English cookbooks spelled the name in several ways, including Paco-Lilla, Piccalillo and Picca Lillo.

What is the difference between piccalilli and Branston Pickle?

Piccalilli is chopped vegetables such as cauliflower, onion and cucumber in a salty-sour mustard and turmeric sauce. Branston Pickle, first made in 1922, is diced vegetables including swede, carrots, onions and cauliflower in a sweet, brown, chutney-like sauce of vinegar, tomato, apple and spices. In CoFID, sweet pickle has more carbohydrate per 100g than piccalilli.

Do they have piccalilli in America?

Yes, but it's often different. Wikipedia says piccalilli in the north-eastern United States is usually based on sweet peppers or green tomatoes, while the Midwest has a bright green, finely chopped gherkin relish nicknamed "neon relish" for Chicago-style hot dogs. In the South, a green tomato relish called chow-chow is sometimes called piccalilli too.

What do you eat piccalilli with?

BBC Food suggests serving piccalilli with raised pies, ham or strong cheeses, or using it to perk up a Scotch egg. Josh Eggleton, writing for Great British Chefs, calls it the greatest accompaniment to rich terrines and cold meats. The Cambridge Dictionary says it's usually eaten with cold meat, so it suits leftover Christmas ham well.

Is piccalilli keto?

Piccalilli isn't carb-free, because recipes usually add sugar and some are thickened with cornflour. CoFID lists 17.6g of carbohydrate per 100g, so a 30g spoonful has about 5.3g. A small spoonful can fit into a keto day if you count it. Homemade versions let you control the sugar and the thickener.

Sources

Back to blog
1 of 4