Layer cake with cream filling on a white stand, topped with berries and a lemon slice, surrounded by strawberries, blueberries, blackberries and halved lemons on marble

Sugar-Free Baking? A UK Guide to Cakes with No Added Sugar

Quick answer

To bake with no added sugar, swap sugar for a granulated sweetener that measures like sugar, such as an erythritol and stevia blend, and swap wheat flour for almond or coconut flour. Expect bakes to brown less and set a little differently, so lower the oven slightly and let cakes cool fully before slicing.

At a glance

  • 1:1our granulated blend swaps for sugar
  • 6.9gcarbs per 100g ground almonds
  • 80.9gcarbs per 100g plain white flour
  • 1gnet carbs per slice, our vanilla cake mix
On this page
  1. Before you start
  2. Swapping sugar: sweeteners that bake well
  3. Swapping flour: low-carb alternatives
  4. Cakes and bakes to try
  5. Tips for baking with no added sugar
  6. Common mistakes and how to fix them
  7. Where to find ingredients in the UK
  8. Frequently asked questions

Searching for sugar-free baking for diabetics? This guide is about baking with no added sugar: which sweeteners and flours to use instead, how they behave in the oven, and which cakes and bakes to start with. It's a practical baking guide, not medical advice.

Most of the swaps come down to two ingredients. Sugar is replaced with a sweetener that measures and bakes like it, and wheat flour is replaced with lower-carb flours such as almond flour. If you'd rather start with a mix, our Keto Baking Mixes include a banana loaf and cakes that you finish with eggs and butter.

Before you start

Baking with no added sugar doesn't make a cake a health food, and no single ingredient swap suits everyone. Fruit, dairy and some flours still contain sugars and carbs, so check the label or the recipe's nutrition figures rather than relying on the name of a bake.

If you have diabetes

Diabetes UK doesn't recommend foods marketed as "diabetic" or "suitable for diabetics". It also says it isn't clear how carbohydrate from polyols such as erythritol should be counted by people who adjust their insulin dose to the carbohydrate they eat, and that people with diabetes should speak to their healthcare team for individual advice.

Swapping sugar: sweeteners that bake well

Sugar does more than sweeten. It adds bulk, helps cakes brown and keeps them moist. Granulated sweeteners based on erythritol do the bulking job best, which is why they're our first choice for sponges, cookies and brownies.

Erythritol is a polyol, also called a sugar alcohol. Some people notice a slight cooling taste, and large amounts can upset the stomach. For more, see what erythritol is and its side effects.

Sweetener How to swap Best for
Granulated Erythritol & Stevia Blend 1:1 for caster or granulated sugar Sponges, cookies, brownies
Powdered Erythritol & Stevia Blend 1:1 for icing sugar Icing, glazes, dusting
Monk Fruit Decoction & Erythritol Sweetener 1:1 for sugar Cakes, crumbles, hot drinks
Liquid Stevia Drops 4–6 drops per serving, to taste Drinks, custards, fillings

Swap ratios and serving sizes from the Groovy Keto product pages.

Honey, maple syrup, agave, dates and dried fruit are often sold as alternatives to sugar, but they're still sugar. Honey, for example, is about 76g of sugars per 100g in the UK government's CoFID data, so we leave these out of bakes with no added sugar.

Swapping flour: low-carb alternatives

Wheat flour is mostly carbohydrate. Nut and seed flours are much lower in carbs and higher in fat and fibre, so they bake differently and usually need more egg to hold together.

Per 100g Carbohydrate
Plain white flour 80.9g
Wholemeal flour 69.9g
Ground almonds 6.9g
Desiccated coconut 6.4g

Source: CoFID 2021 (Composition of Foods Integrated Dataset, GOV.UK). As on UK labels, carbohydrate excludes fibre.

  • Almond flour: the base of most of our bakes. It gives a moist, tender crumb, but it's heavier than wheat flour and browns faster. Our guide to almond flour explains how to use it.
  • Coconut flour: very absorbent, so you need far less of it and more liquid or egg. See coconut flour on keto.
  • Oat fibre: adds bulk with very few digestible carbs. Our oat fibre guide covers how much to use.
  • Psyllium husk and xanthan gum: without gluten, bakes need help to hold together. A little psyllium husk gives bread-like structure (see our psyllium guide), and a pinch of xanthan gum stops cakes crumbling.

If you're used to banana bread, ripe bananas are high in sugar. Our banana-on-keto guide explains why, and our banana bread mix gets its flavour from banana powder instead.

Cakes and bakes to try

Chocolate layer cakes and slices with cream filling on white plates and cake stands, topped with raspberries and blueberries and dusted with powdered sweetener, on a wooden table

These are our easiest starting points. Each of these mixes is made with almond flour, and the carb figures below come from the product pages.

Mix Portion Net carbs
Keto Vanilla Cake Mix 1 slice 1g
Keto Chocolate Cake Mix 1 slice 1g
Keto Carrot Cake Mix 1 slice 1.7g
Keto Banana Bread Mix 1 slice 2.5g
Keto Chocolate Brownie Mix 1 brownie 0.8g

Net carbs per portion from the Groovy Keto product pages. The vanilla, chocolate, carrot cake and brownie figures include the eggs and butter you add. The vanilla cake, chocolate cake, carrot cake and banana bread mixes contain milk, and all five contain almonds.

A classic sponge

A plain sponge is the best test of a sugar swap. Start with our Keto Vanilla Cake Mix and fill it with whipped cream and a few berries. Finish with a dusting of our Powdered Erythritol & Stevia Blend instead of icing sugar. For a from-scratch version, try our keto Victoria sponge, made with no added sugar.

A rich chocolate cake

For a deep chocolate flavour, use our Keto Chocolate Cake Mix and stir in a handful of our keto dark chocolate buttons, which are at least 64% cocoa and sweetened with erythritol and stevia. Melt a few more over the top for a simple ganache.

Cheesecake

Cheesecake suits low-carb baking well because most of it is cream cheese and eggs. Our Keto Cheesecake with Almond Flour uses an almond flour base and our erythritol & stevia blend.

Mug cakes

When you only want one portion, a mug cake needs just an egg and a tablespoon of melted butter, then 60 seconds in the microwave. Our mug cake variety pack (8 flavours) has one mix of each flavour, or try the Chocolate Mug Cake Mix on its own. See all our Keto Mug Cake Mixes.

Brownies

Brownies are forgiving, because they're meant to be dense. Make them from scratch with our Keto Chocolate Brownies recipe, adding our chocolate chips with no added sugar, which are sweetened with erythritol and stevia. Our guide on how to bake with our chocolate chips has more ideas. For a shortcut, use our Keto Chocolate Brownie Mix.

Carrot cake and banana bread

Spiced bakes hide the taste of sweeteners well. Our Keto Carrot Cake Mix uses carrot powder, cinnamon and nutmeg, and goes well with a cream cheese frosting sweetened with the powdered blend. Our banana bread mix is a good weekend bake.

For more ideas, browse our Keto Recipes.

Groovy Keto Chocolate Brownie Mix pouch, front

Easiest start

Keto Chocolate Brownie Mix

0.8g net carbs per brownie, as baked

See the brownie mix
Groovy Keto Carrot Cake Mix pouch, front

Spiced classic

Keto Carrot Cake Mix

1.7g net carbs per slice, as baked

See the carrot cake mix
Groovy Keto Monk Fruit Decoction and Erythritol Sweetener 500g pouch, front

Swap for sugar

Monk Fruit Decoction & Erythritol Sweetener

Measures 1:1 like sugar

See the sweetener

Tips for baking with no added sugar

Weigh everything

Almond and coconut flour are much lighter or heavier per cup than wheat flour, so cup measures can be badly out. Use digital scales and weigh flours, sweeteners and liquids in grams. With coconut flour, even 10g too much can make a cake dry.

Lower the heat and check early

Nut flours brown faster than wheat flour. Bake about 10–20°C lower than a standard recipe and check 5–10 minutes before the stated time. If the top browns before the middle sets, cover it loosely with foil.

Let bakes cool fully

Low-carb cakes and cookies are fragile when warm and firm up as they cool. Leave them in the tin for 10–15 minutes, then cool completely on a rack before slicing.

Keeping cakes moist

Without sugar to hold moisture, cakes can dry out. Add a spoonful of soured cream or Greek yoghurt to the batter, and store slices in an airtight tin. Most cakes and brownies freeze well for up to three months.

Common mistakes and how to fix them

  • Too much sweetener: more sweetener doesn't make a better cake and can leave a cooling aftertaste. Stick to the 1:1 swap, taste the batter and adjust next time.
  • Crunchy icing: granulated erythritol can turn gritty or crystallise as it cools. Use the powdered blend for icing, buttercream and glazes.
  • Crumbly cakes: gluten-free flours need a binder. Add an extra egg, a pinch of xanthan gum or a little psyllium husk.
  • Dense or wet middles: almond flour bakes are heavier, so don't overfill the tin, and use a skewer to check the centre rather than going by colour.

Where to find ingredients in the UK

Ground almonds, coconut flour, cream cheese and eggs are in most UK supermarkets. Erythritol, monk fruit blends, psyllium husk and xanthan gum are easiest to find online or in health food shops. Always check the ingredients list, because some "low sugar" products still contain sugar, honey or syrups.

Our own baking range includes:

Key takeaways

  • Swap sugar 1:1. A granulated erythritol blend measures like sugar; use the powdered version for icing.
  • Swap the flour. Almond flour has 6.9g of carbs per 100g, against 80.9g for plain white flour.
  • Bake lower and cool fully. Nut flours brown fast and set as they cool.
  • Read the label. Honey, syrups and dried fruit are still sugar.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use honey instead of sugar in baking?

You can, but honey is still sugar. The UK government's CoFID data lists honey at about 76g of sugars per 100g, so it doesn't make a bake lower in sugar. For baking with no added sugar, use a granulated erythritol and stevia blend, which swaps 1:1 for sugar.

Will almond flour change the texture of my cakes?

Yes. Almond flour gives a moister, denser and more tender crumb than wheat flour, and it browns faster. Bake 10–20°C lower than a standard recipe, add a pinch of xanthan gum or an extra egg to help it hold together, and let the cake cool completely before slicing.

Can I freeze bakes made with no added sugar?

Yes, most freeze well for up to three months. Cool them completely, wrap slices individually, then freeze in an airtight container. Defrost at room temperature for one to two hours. Ice cakes after defrosting, because icing made with powdered erythritol can weep or crystallise once frozen and thawed.

Why does my low-carb cake crumble?

Low-carb flours have no gluten to hold the crumb together, and warm cakes are fragile. Add an extra egg, a pinch of xanthan gum or a little psyllium husk, weigh your flour carefully, and leave the cake in its tin for 10–15 minutes before cooling it fully on a rack.

Does erythritol have side effects?

Erythritol is a polyol, or sugar alcohol. The NHS says polyols can have a laxative effect in large amounts, and products where added polyols make up more than 10% must carry a warning. Some people also notice a slight cooling taste. Start with small portions to see how you get on.

Sources

Back to blog
1 of 4